Which channels bring subscribers back for a second shipment?
Illustrative assessment for a fictional coffee roaster. All figures are invented.
How the data reaches the report
Campaign link → signup source on the first order → subscription ID → first and second fulfilled shipments. We use the subscription ID to connect shipments, including those delayed by a skip.
Which numbers support the decision?
Of 100 subscriptions started in January, 60 had a second shipment within 90 days. The fulfillment records support that total. The signup source is missing for 30 subscriptions, which limits the channel comparison.
| Signup source | Signups | Second shipment | Rate |
|---|---|---|---|
| Paid search | 40 | 24 | 60% |
| 30 | 21 | 70% | |
| Unknown | 30 | 15 | 50% |
Decision: Use 60% as the overall baseline. Hold off on shifting budget toward email based on this comparison alone. The 30 unassigned signups could change the ranking.
What to fix first
- Find where the source drops out. Run a tagged test signup through each checkout path and compare the original link with the source stored on the subscription.
- Repair the affected handoff. Retest it through a renewal and confirm the original signup source stays attached.
- Recheck the decision. Monitor missing sources on new signups, then compare second shipments once the next cohort has had the same 90 days.